Hallmark isn’t putting away the crime tape just yet. Mistletoe Murders has officially been renewed for Season 3 — proving that even in a world of twinkling lights and peppermint lattes, there’s always room for a little murder.
At the heart of the series is Emily Lane, played by Sarah Drew — a cheerful, driven entrepreneur who owns a year-round Christmas-themed shop. On the surface, Emily is all warmth and holiday spirit. But beneath the festive sweaters and perfectly wrapped gifts lies a sharp mind — and a past filled with secrets.
And then there’s Detective Sam Wilner, portrayed by Peter Mooney. Calm, observant, and grounded, Sam becomes Emily’s unlikely partner in solving crimes that seem to pop up as regularly as Christmas decorations in July.
Because in this town, the mistletoe isn’t the only thing hanging overhead…
What makes Mistletoe Murders stand out is its tonal blend. Hallmark is known for romance and comfort, but this series adds a twist of suspense without losing the network’s signature warmth. Yes, there are crimes. Yes, there are secrets. But there are also cozy storefronts, candlelit dinners, and slow-burn chemistry that keeps fans invested beyond the mystery itself.
The dynamic between Emily and Sam is key. Their partnership balances charm and tension — professional curiosity mixed with emotional undercurrents. As each case unfolds, so does their connection, giving viewers two storylines to follow: who committed the crime… and whether these two will finally admit what’s growing between them.
Season 2 raised the stakes.
Secrets deepened. Trust was
